Cold Environments - Control Measures

What factors modify our response to cold?

A cold environment challenges the worker in three ways: air temperature, air movement (wind speed), and humidity (wetness). In order to work safely, these challenges have to be counterbalanced by proper insulation (layered protective clothing), physical activity, and controlled exposure to cold (work/rest schedule). Air Temperature: Air temperature is measured by an ordinary thermometer in degrees Celsius (°C) or degrees Fahrenheit (°F). Wind Speed: Different types of commercially available anemometers can be used to measure wind speed or air movement. These are calibrated in metres per second (m/s), kilometres per hour (km/h), or miles per hour (mph). Air movement is usually measured in m/s while wind speed is usually measured in km/h or mph. The following is a suggested guide for estimating wind speed if accurate information is not available: Humidity (wetness): Air humidity is measured by a hygrometer in percent relative humidity (%RH). As humidity increases, more moisture from the air can be absorbed by clothing, which reduces its ability to insulate. The absorbed moisture “wicks” away (evaporates) which can accelerate heat loss through conduction. Physical Activity: The production of body heat by physical activity (metabolic rate) is difficult to measure. However, tables showing metabolic rates for a variety of activities are available in the literature. Metabolic heat production is measured in kilocalories (kcal) per hour. One kilocalorie is the amount of heat needed to raise the temperature of one kilogram of water by 1°C. Work/rest schedule: The “work warm-up schedule,” as developed by the Saskatchewan Occupational Health and Safety Division identifies how many breaks are recommended when working in cold conditions. The schedule applies to any four-hour period with moderate or heavy activity and assumes that "normal breaks" are taken once every two hours. At the end of a 4-hour period, an extended break in a warm location is recommended. Protective clothing: Check the section on “What should I know about personal protective equipment (PPE) for working in the cold?” For information on the general effects of working in the cold as well as how the body adapts to cold, please see Cold Environments - Overview. For information on the health effects and first aid for cold-related injuries and illnesses, please see Cold Environments - Health Effects and First Aid.

• context 8 km/h (5 mph): light flag moves,
• context 16 km/h (10 mph): light flag fully extended,
• context 24 km/h (15 mph): raises dust and loose paper,
• context 32 km/h (20 mph): causes blowing and drifting snow.

What is the wind chill temperature?

• context At any temperature, you feel colder as the wind speed increases. The combined effect of cold air and wind speed is expressed simply as the “wind chill” or "wind chill index". It is essentially the air temperature that would feel the same on exposed human flesh as the given combination of air temperature and wind speed. It can be used as a general guideline for deciding clothing requirements and the possible health effects of the cold.
• context Environment and Climate Change Canada has produced a Wind Chill Temperature Index and guides to help estimate wind chill and wind speed.
• context NOTE: Environment and Climate Change Canada's recommendations consider all individuals who may be outside, including young children and the elderly. These recommendations are helpful, they may not match exposure values or precautions developed by other organizations that have specifically made recommendations for working adults who are assumed to be in good general health.
• context The American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) developed recommendations to protect workers from the most severe effects of cold stress (hypothermia and frostbite). The recommendations also describe cold working conditions under which it is believed nearly all workers can be repeatedly exposed without adverse health effects. Included in these recommendations is the wind chill temperature index.
• context The Wind Chill Temperature (WCT) index estimates how cold it feels considering both air temperatures and wind speeds. The WCT table also provides the estimated time it would take a person walking at 3 kilometres per hour to experience freezing of exposed facial skin. Note that if the skin is wet and exposed to wind, the air temperature measurement used to determine the WCT should be 10°C lower than the actual temperature.
• context Source: Adapted from Threshold Limit Values (TLV) and Biological Exposure Indices (BEI) booklet: published by ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio, 2024, page 226.

What are some health concerns of working in cold temperatures?

The following chart from Environment Canada describes the health concerns and potential for frostbite when being outside at various temperatures. NOTE: Environment Canada's recommendations consider all individuals who may be outside, including young children and the elderly. While these recommendations are helpful, they may not match exposure values developed by other organizations that have specifically made recommendations for working adults who are assumed to be in good general health. From: "Wind Chill Index" Environment Canada (2017)

• context Slight increase in discomfort
• context Dress warmly
• context Stay dry
• context Uncomfortable
• context Risk of hypothermia and frostbite if outside for long periods without adequate protection.
• context Dress in layers of warm clothing, with an outer layer that is wind-resistant.
• context Wear a hat, mittens or insulated gloves, a scarf and insulated, waterproof footwear.
• context Stay dry.
• context Keep active
• context High risk of frostnip or frostbite: Check face and extremities for numbness or whiteness.
• context High risk of hypothermia if outside for long periods without adequate clothing or shelter from wind and cold.
• context Dress in layers of warm clothing, with an outer layer that is wind-resistant
• context Cover exposed skin
• context Wear a hat, mittens or insulated gloves, a scarf, neck tube or face mask and insulated, waterproof footwear
• context Stay dry
• context Keep active
• context Very high risk of frostbite: Check face and extremities for numbness or whiteness.
• context Very high risk of hypothermia if outside for long periods without adequate clothing or shelter from wind and cold.
• context Dress in layers of warm clothing, with an outer layer that is wind-resistant.
• context Cover all exposed skin.
• context Wear a hat, mittens or insulated gloves, a scarf, neck tube or face mask and insulated, waterproof footwear.
• context Stay dry
• context Keep active.
• context Severe risk of frostbite: Check face and extremities frequently for numbness or whiteness.
• context Severe risk of hypothermia if outside for long periods without adequate clothing or shelter from wind and cold.
• context Be careful. Dress very warmly in layers of clothing, with an outer layer that is wind-resistant.
• context Cover all exposed skin
• context Wear a hat, mittens or insulated gloves, a scarf, neck tube or face mask and insulated, waterproof footwear.
• context Be ready to cut short or cancel outdoor activities.
• context Stay dry.
• context Keep active.
• context DANGER! Outdoor conditions are hazardous.
• context Stay indoors.

Are there exposure limits for working in cold environments?

In Canada, legislation from some jurisdictions provides a range of acceptable temperatures for specific circumstances. In other cases, occupational health and safety jurisdictions use the Threshold Limit Values® for cold stress as published by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH). Some Canadian jurisdictions have adopted these TLVs as occupational exposure limits and others use them as guidelines. Where there are no maximum or minimum exposure limits for cold working environments, there are guidelines that can be used to conduct risk assessments, create safe work plans, and monitor conditions to protect the health and safety of workers who may be exposed to cold temperatures. Where there are differences between the recommendations made by various organizations (and where there are no established limits or guidelines from your jurisdiction), employers are encouraged to choose a system that best provides protection for their workforce. For example, ACGIH suggests a work-warming regimen when work is done continuously in the cold when the wind chill temperature is at or below -7°C (19.4°F). Heated warming shelters such as tents, cabins, or rest rooms should be made available nearby and used at regular intervals. Workers should be encouraged to use these shelters, depending on the severity of the exposure. If signs of cold stress are noticed, return to the shelter immediately. For work at or below -12°C (10.4°F), work should include:

• context constant observation (supervisor or buddy system)
• context adjusting the pace or rate of work so that it is not too high and cause heavy sweating that will result in wet clothing
• context time for new employees to become accustomed to the conditions
• context adjustments to include the weight and bulkiness of the clothing when estimating work performance and weights to be lifted by the worker
• context arrangements to minimize sitting and standing for long periods
• context instructions in safe work practices, re-warming procedures, proper clothing practices, proper eating and drinking habits, recognition of cold stress/frostbite, and signs and symptoms of hypothermia or excessive cooling of the body (including when shivering does not occur)

What personal protective equipment (PPE) can be used for working in the cold?

Clothing

Protective clothing is needed for work in cold environments. Clothing should be selected to suit the temperature, weather conditions (e.g., wind speed, rain), the level and duration of activity, and job design. These factors are important to consider so that you can regulate the amount of heat and perspiration you generate while working. If the work pace is too fast or if the type and amount of clothing are not properly selected, excessive sweating may occur. The clothing next to the body will become wet and the insulation value of the clothing will decrease dramatically. This reduction in insulation value increases the risk of cold injuries and illnesses.

• context Clothing should be worn in multiple layers which provide better protection than a single thick garment. The air between layers of clothing provides better insulation than the clothing itself. Having several layers also gives you the option to open or remove a layer before you get too warm and start sweating or to add a layer when you take a break. Layers also allow you to accommodate the level of activity, changing temperatures and weather conditions. Successive outer layers should be larger than the inner layer, otherwise the outermost layer will compress the inner layers and will decrease the insulation properties of the clothing.
• context The inner layer should provide insulation and be able to “wick” moisture away from the skin to help keep it dry. Thermal underwear made from wool, polyester, or polypropylene is suitable for this purpose. Polypropylene wicks perspiration away from the skin. It also keeps the second layer away from the skin.
• context The additional layers of clothing should provide adequate insulation for the weather conditions under which the work is being done. They should also be easy to open or remove before you get too warm to prevent excessive sweating during strenuous activity. Outer jackets should have the means for closing off and opening the waist, neck, and wrists to help control how much heat is retained or given off. Some jackets have netted pockets and vents around the trunk and under the armpits (with zippers or Velcro fasteners) for added ventilation.
• context For work in wet conditions, the outer layer of clothing should be waterproof.
• context If the work area cannot be shielded against wind, an easily removable windbreak garment should be used.
• context Under extremely cold conditions, heated protective clothing should be made available if the work cannot be done on a warmer day.
• context Wear a hat suitable for the conditions, including being able to keep the ears warm. If a hard hat is required, a knit cap or a liner under a hard hat can reduce excessive heat loss. Consult with the hard hat supplier or manufacturer for appropriate liners that do not compromise the protection provided by the hard hat.
• context Clothing should be kept clean since dirt fills air cells in fibres of clothing and destroys its insulating ability.
• context Clothing must be dry. Moisture should be kept off clothes by removing snow before entering heated shelters. While the worker is resting in a heated area, perspiration should be allowed to escape by opening the neck, waist, sleeves, and ankle fasteners or by removing outerwear. If the rest area is warm enough it is preferable to take off the outer layer(s) so that the perspiration can evaporate from the clothing.
• context If fine manual dexterity is not required, gloves should be used below 4°C for light work and below -7°C for moderate work. For work below -17°C, mittens should be used.
• context Cotton is not recommended. It tends to get damp or wet quickly and loses its insulating properties. Wool and synthetic fibres, on the other hand, do retain heat when wet.

Footwear

• context Felt-lined, rubber-bottomed, leather-topped boots with removable felt insoles are best suited for heavy work in cold since leather is porous, allowing the boots to “breathe” and let perspiration evaporate. Leather boots can be “waterproofed” with some products that do not block the pores in the leather. However, if work involves standing in water or slush (e.g., fire fighting, farming), then waterproof boots must be worn. While these protect the feet from getting wet from cold water in the work environment, they also prevent perspiration from escaping. The insulating materials and socks will become wet more quickly than when wearing leather boots and increase the risk of frostbite.
• context Foot Comfort and Safety at Work has some general information about how to select footwear. (Also, when trying on boots before purchase, wear the same type of sock that you would wear at work to ensure a proper fit.)

Socks

• context You may prefer to wear one pair of thick, bulky socks or two pairs - one inner sock of silk, nylon, or thin wool and a slightly larger, thick outer sock. Liner socks made from polypropylene will help keep feet dry and warmer by wicking sweat away from the skin. However, as the outer sock becomes more damp, its insulation properties decrease. If work conditions permit, have extra socks available so you can dry your feet and change socks during the day. If two pairs of socks are worn, the outer sock should be a larger size so that the inner sock is not compressed.
• context Always wear the right thickness of socks for your boots. If they are too thick, the boots will be “tight,” and the socks will lose much of their insulating properties are compressed inside the boot. The foot would also be “squeezed” which would slow the blood flow to the feet and increase the risk of cold injuries. If the socks are too thin, the boots will fit loosely and may lead to blisters.